Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Alexander's Feast with Philharmonia Baroque

There was a gorgeous performance of Handel's oratorio Alexander's Feast at Herbst Theatre last Friday presented by the Philharmonia Baroque Orchestra. (All of the great photos are by Scott Chernis, with most of the following taken in performance at Stanford Live on Thursday.)
Founded in 1981 by the late harpsichordist and scholar Laurette Goldberg, the Philharmonia Baroque Orchestra was led by Nicholas McGegan from 1985 to 2020. After his retirement as Music Director, his successor was a bit of a disaster and only lasted a few years before being replaced by a rotating roster of guest conductors. This year, the Irish conductor Peter Whelan was named the new Music Director and he's been making a great impression on everyone.
Alexander's Feast was written in 1736 when the craze for Italian opera in London was losing its commercial appeal and Handel began writing oratorios instead. Musically, I tend to prefer the latter because they include a chorus while the operas do not. For these performances, it helped that the 24-member Philharmonia Chorale sounded superb.
The three soloists were more of a mixed bag. Soprano Sherezade Panthaki has a lovely voice but Handel's vocal lines are extremely exposed and she kept sliding into the edges of off-pitch territory.
The tenor James Way also has a handsome voice that can handle rapid-fire ornamentation but he took the martial air of the music a little too literally and kept punching out his arias in a way that didn't do them any favors.
The mezzo-soprano Rachael Wilson, however, was creamy, dreamy perfection, caressing the musical lines with both care and voluptuousness. I hope to hear her again singing pretty much anything.
Handel revised the very successful oratorio on a 1942 trip to Dublin, Ireland, adding a 12-minute Act III in a version that's virtually unknown, and Whelan has been spearheading its restoration. Because audiences of the time demanded overstuffed concerts, the performance tradition of Alexander's Feast included interpolations of other Handel music between the acts, and this weekend's program included a couple of movements from Water Music and the Concerto Grosso Op. 3, No. 2. Whelan's lithe, energetic, fast-paced conducting style while jumping up and down at the harpsichord sounds great and is a kick to watch. He's a wonderful addition to San Francisco's music world.

No comments: